Are You My First?': Bachelor Nation Stars Weigh In on Hulu's Shocking Virgin Dating Show

2025-08-19
Are You My First?': Bachelor Nation Stars Weigh In on Hulu's Shocking Virgin Dating Show
Hollywood Reporter

Hulu’s latest reality dating show, 'Are You My First?', is turning heads with its unique premise: singles seeking partners who are also virgins. Former 'Bachelor' franchise stars Kaitlyn Bristowe and Colton Underwood are sharing their thoughts on the show’s bold concept and the complexities it raises. Bristowe, known for her bubbly personality and insightful commentary, and Underwood, who has publicly shared his own journey of self-discovery, offer perspectives on whether 'sex sells' – or if the absence of it is the true draw. Plus, get the scoop on Underwood's upcoming role on 'The Traitors,' and how he's navigating the world of reality TV.
A Radical Dating Experiment

In a landscape saturated with dating shows centered around hookups and fleeting connections, 'Are You My First?' dares to be different. The show brings together a group of individuals who have all chosen to remain virgins, searching for someone who shares their values and commitment to a slower, more meaningful approach to relationships. It's a concept that has sparked both curiosity and controversy, prompting viewers to question societal norms around intimacy and dating.

Kaitlyn Bristowe's Candid Take

Kaitlyn Bristowe, a beloved figure from 'The Bachelorette' and 'Bachelor in Paradise,' doesn't shy away from sharing her honest opinions. “It’s wild, right?” Bristowe admits. “But honestly, I think it’s fascinating. It’s forcing people to connect on a deeper level, without the physical aspect clouding things. Will it work? Who knows! But it's certainly a conversation starter.” She believes the show's success hinges on the genuine connections formed between the participants and their willingness to be vulnerable.

Colton Underwood's Perspective & 'The Traitors'

Colton Underwood, who famously came out as gay and has since become an advocate for LGBTQ+ rights, also weighs in.

Recommendations
Recommendations