The AFL landscape is buzzing with excitement over the recent influx of talent, and the race for the coveted recruit of the year title is heating up. While Geelong superstar Bailey Smith has long been considered a frontrunner, Fremantle's acquisition of Shai Bolton is seriously challenging his position. AFL.com.au’s Josh Gabelich is leading the charge in highlighting Bolton’s impact, sparking a debate across the league about who deserves the ultimate recognition.

Fremantle made a significant investment to secure Bolton from Richmond during the trade period, parting ways with a staggering three first-round picks while receiving one in return. This bold move immediately signaled the Dockers' intent to bolster their midfield and add a dynamic spark to their attack. The gamble appears to be paying off handsomely.

Bolton's electrifying pace, dazzling skills, and uncanny ability to create scoring opportunities have instantly resonated with Fremantle fans. He's brought a unique flavour to the team, injecting a sense of unpredictability and excitement that was previously lacking. His performances haven’t just been about highlights; he's consistently contributed across the board, demonstrating a willingness to tackle, assist, and play a selfless role within the team structure.

But let's not dismiss Bailey Smith’s contributions to Geelong. Smith remains a pivotal figure for the Cats, consistently delivering strong performances and demonstrating his leadership qualities. His work rate, tackling prowess, and ability to find space are undeniable assets to the Geelong lineup. He's a proven performer who has already established himself as a key player.

The key difference, according to many observers, lies in the immediate impact Bolton has had on Fremantle. Smith’s contributions were always expected given his established pedigree, but Bolton has arguably exceeded expectations, rapidly becoming a 'difference-maker' in the truest sense of the term. He's revitalized the Fremantle attack and provided a much-needed boost to their midfield.

The debate isn’t just about individual brilliance; it’s also about the impact on team performance. Has Bolton’s arrival significantly improved Fremantle's chances of premiership contention? That’s a question many are asking. While Geelong are already a strong contender, the addition of Bolton has undeniably elevated Fremantle's status.

As the season progresses, the comparison between Bolton and Smith will only intensify. It promises to be a thrilling race, with both players showcasing their talents and vying for the prestigious recruit of the year crown. One thing is certain: the AFL is witnessing a fascinating rivalry unfold, one that is captivating fans and shaping the future of the league. Will Bolton continue his impressive form and usurp Smith’s position? Only time will tell.

Ultimately, the decision will rest on which player has demonstrably contributed more to their team's success. While Smith’s consistency is admirable, Bolton’s explosive impact and immediate difference-making ability are proving difficult to ignore. The 'Kozzy-like' quality - that unique ability to change a game in an instant - is certainly present in Bolton’s play.